Best Christmas Albums of All Time

As I’ve posted here many times, I’ve become something of a Christmas music aficionado over the years. As such, I’ve accumulated quite the holiday music library. For the past several weeks, I’ve been listening through my Christmas playlists over and over. Here are the top 5 Christmas albums on my iPod. Feel free to let me know your thoughts.

5. Martina McBride, White Christmas
Martina is at the top of Sunny’s list of favorite artists. She released a holiday album a few years back, but this updated version includes all of those previous songs as well as a few new ones. For my money, there is no finer female vocalist alive than Martina McBride. We could listen to this one around the clock. Essential tracks: Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas, O Holy Night

4. Vince Guaraldi, Charlie Brown Christmas
And listening to this album makes me nostalgic for the Christmases of my childhood. Top to bottom, this is a great holiday album and it needs to be a part of your library. I’m surprised that this album is this low on my list. It should probably rank higher on longevity alone, but I can’t move it past any of the top three, at least not at the moment. Guaraldi’s vintage soundtrack made the Charlie Brown Christmas special an instant classic back in 1965. By the way, I think this album is available on eMusic. If you’re a music lover, you need to be on eMusic. Essential tracks: Christmas Time Is Here, Hark the Herald Angels Sing

3. Third Day, Christmas Offerings
Third Day has been a favorite of mine for a decade; and while I love every one of their “Offerings” recordings, this one sits at the top of my list. What I love about this album is that each song embodies the glorious wonder of the Incarnation and the pronouncement of the Christ child’s birth as “Good News”. No schmaltzy novelty songs; no Rudolph or Frosty; just songs that exalt the name of Jesus. I’ve heard people say this before, but this is the only Christmas album that falls into this category for me: I could listen to this music any time of the year. Essential tracks: Joy to the World, Merry Christmas

2. Harry Connick, Jr., Harry for the Holidays
I always felt that Harry Connick’s first Christmas album, When My Heart Finds Christmas, was his essential holiday recording. And when he released Harry for the Holidays in 2003, I’ll admit, I thought it was somewhat derivative at first. But this album has slowly grown on me over the years, so much so that it has surpassed When My Heart Finds Christmas and ranks #2 on my all-time list. All 16 songs are simply amazing. Essential tracks: Frosty the Snowman, This Christmas

1. Elvis Presley, Elvis’ Christmas Album
Big surprise, right? This stuff is just awesome. I’m a passing fan of the King’s more popular non-seasonal stuff, but this Christmas album is far and away my favorite. This is the album that made me love Christmas music. I absolutely dare you to listen to “Blue Christmas” and not do a lip-quivering imitation. Nary a bad track to be found on this one. This one will always be a holiday tradition around the Bybee house. Essential tracks: Blue Christmas, Santa Claus is Back in Town

This entry was posted in Christmas, Music. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Best Christmas Albums of All Time

  1. Unknown's avatar greg says:

    we have harry connick’s When My Heart Finds Christmas, but I’ve not heard this one. He also has a brand new Christmas album out, released last month.My wife is a big fan of his. We saw him here in Little Rock back in the late 90’s and he was outstanding. I don’t sit around and listen to him a lot, but he was great in concert.I also like Third Day’s Christmas album more than most of the stuff they’ve done lately. It’s pretty good.

  2. Unknown's avatar Sunny says:

    The Charlie Brown Christmas really surprises me! One of my favorite Christmas albums is Amy Grant’s, A Christmas To Remember. I would have to say that the kids’ favorite is the Cedarmont Kids, Christmas Favorites. I’m so glad that you have joined me in my love for Christmas music! Hands down, Martina McBride’s Christmas CD is the best in my book. Harry Connick Jr.’s CD comes in a close second for me!

  3. Unknown's avatar Jason says:

    Greg,The latest Harry Connick Christmas album is my least favorite. It’s still solid, but I don’t think it’s anywhere near as good as his first two. I wanted to take Sunny to see him at the Ryman this coming Sunday, but tix were all sold out. She LOVES Harry Connick. Sunny, You’re definitely to blame for my Christmas music obsession!

  4. Unknown's avatar Jason says:

    And why does Charlie Brown surprise you? It’s awesome!

  5. Unknown's avatar Treasures By Brenda says:

    How did you manage to pick just a few!?! That is an impossible task!I have been listening to and enjoying the new Elvis Presley Christmas Duets album. I think it is great…and it includes two artists from your list — Martina McBride and Elvis Presley.I also wrote a page about the opportunity to do a duet to Blue Christmas with Elvis and send it as an eCard. You might enjoy it and can find it at Sing With Elvis Presley and Record Your Song As A Christmas eCard.Merry Christmas and Happy Listening!Brenda

  6. Unknown's avatar Jason says:

    Thanks for stopping by, Brenda.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.