Franchise Players

This month, Baseball Tonight is ranking the top players in each MLB franchise’s history. Follow this link and you can vote from among several all-time greats on each team to help determine each club’s “Franchise Player”. For a baseball geek like me, this is just my kind of thing. In case you’re wondering, here’s my ballot.

Cards – Musial. At least for now. In 10 years, it’ll probably be Pujols. But for now, Stan’s the Man.

Reds – My gut says Bench, but this is tough. Morgan was great; according to Bill James, the greatest 2B of all-time. But I dock him points for his insipid television commentary. Frank Robinson also deserves consideration. Ultimately, though, these two also did significant damage with other clubs. Bench gets the nod.

White Sox – Eddie Collins, the 2nd greatest 2B of all-time.

Giants – This is impossible. Matthewson, McCovey, Ott, Mays. The Giants have had some great players. But you absolutely have to vote for Bonds. If you don’t, you’re crazy.

Blue Jays – What, no Garth Iorg? Kelly Gruber? There’s no real clear-cut choice here, so I’ll go with Delgado since he was there for a decade.

Astros – Bagwell.

Nats / Expos – Tim Raines. Man, the Expos had some talent. How come they never won?

Cubs – Ernie Banks.

Brewers – This is a close call with Yount and Molitor. I’ll take Yount because he played the field more regularly.

Diamondbacks – This is where it gets absurd. Randy Johnson, but who really cares?

Padres – Gwynn, with a nod to Hoffman.

Marlins – Pick ’em. I went with Conine simply because he’s known as “Mr. Marlin”. That has to be the lamest nickname ever.

Royals – Brett. Why even put anybody else on the list?

Pirates – Honus Wagner, although I really wanted to vote for Clemente.

Devil Rays – Again, who cares? Carl Crawford, I guess.

Angels – This is another one without a clear cut favorite. I haven’t looked at the numbers, but I imagine Garrett Anderson and Tim Salmon have similar career numbers. I’ll go with Salmon simply because he has a few years on Anderson.

Senators / Twins – I kind of wish they could split this one. It’s hard not to vote for Walter Johnson, but he played in a different era. He’d get my Senators vote and Kirby would get my Twins vote.

Indians – This is one classic franchise that doesn’t have that one all-time great, in my opinion. I guess you could argue for Feller or Lajoie, but I’m going with Larry Doby for his contribution to help integrate MLB. He’s considered the “American League’s Jackie Robinson”.

Mariners – Griffey.

Mets – Another tough one. I’ll go with Seaver, though. Random thought: Do any of you remember when Gregg Jeffries’ rookie card was worth like $20? Everybody thought he was the second coming of Pete Rose back in the late ’80s. Too bad he couldn’t even beat out Wally Backman for the starting 2B job.

Rockies – Helton. Go Vols.

A’s – I think there are four deserving candidates here: Henderson, Foxx, Reggie, and Simmons. Just for argument’s sake, I’ll say Rickey, although several of his best years came with other clubs.

Orioles – Ripken, with Murray receiving an honorable mention.

Tigers – Cobb. No brainer.

Rangers – Nolan Ryan is probably more identifiable with this club than anybody else, but I think Juan Gone is the choice here.

Braves – Aaron. No brainer.

Phillies – Schmidt. Greatest 3B of all-time.

Red Sox – This is an impressive list. The Splendid Splinter, Ted Williams, is by far the choice, though.

Yankees – Another slam dunk, in my opinion. Ruth is the greatest player who ever lived. The real question is who ranks #2 on this list? DiMaggio? Mantle? Gehrig? I’m tempted to give DiMaggio the slightest nod over Gehrig, but not by much.

Dodgers – Although his career was cut short by injury, Koufax was absolutely the best pitcher ever for about a six-year stretch there. I thought long and hard about Jackie here, but my gut says Koufax was greater, if even for a shorter period of time.

Your thoughts?

This entry was posted in Baseball. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Franchise Players

  1. Unknown's avatar matt w. says:

    This has nothing to do with the poll, but have you noticed that the Dodgers have put together a team that is poised to win the 2003 World Series? Nomar, Kent, Manny, Andruw, Pierre, Furcal, Schmidt, Lowe . . .There would have been no stopping this team 5 years ago.

  2. Unknown's avatar Allen says:

    I would disagree with the following:Indians: your pick of Doby is based on emotion. It has to be Feller.Marlins: as you stated, the significance of this with such a slight history is negligible, but Gary Sheffield is the best choice.Twins: Walter Johnson is the top pick, but you left Harmon Killebrew out of the discussion.Rangers- Gonzalez, not Ivan Rodriguez?Dodgers- Koufax was, for 6 seasons, virtually unhittable. My dad is a USC alum and saw Koufax at Dodger Stadium numerous times. I’m a Koufax guy. But I wonder if a better choice might not be Duke Snider.

  3. Unknown's avatar Anonymous says:

    Braves – Francisco CabereaNationals / Expos – Steve RogersPhillies – Juan SamuelMets – Rusty StaubMarlins – Charlie HoughPirates – Randall SimonReds – Tome HumeAstros – JR RichardCubs – Steve StoneBrewers – Gorman ThomasGiants – Atlee HammakerPadres – Randy JonesRockies – SnowDodgers – Terry ForsterDiamondbacks – Buck ShowalterYankees – Dale BerraRed Sox – Glenn HoffmanBlue Jays – Dave SteibO’s – Storm DavisRays- Thunder DomeTigers – Chet LemonWhite Sox – Greg LuzunskiTwins – Gary GaettiRoyals – U.L WashingtonIndians – Len BarkerAngels – Donnie MooreRangers – Toby HarrahMariners – Lenny RandleA’s – Billy Ball

  4. Unknown's avatar Allen says:

    Y’know, Stieb’s actually a pretty solid choice for Toronto. But as much as I liked U.L. Washington as a kid in K.C. (he of the ever-present toothpick), I still gotta go with a Hall of Famer like George Brett. I also like the choice of “Tome” Hume (he doubles as a book, apparently).Little known fact, Jason; Brett is the only player in MLB history to retire with the following smorgasboard of statistics:3,000 hits600 doubles300 home runs200 stolen bases100 triplesSorry, it’s just the Royals fan in me.

  5. Unknown's avatar Jason says:

    Matt,I usually end up assembling fantasy teams just like these Dodgers; teams that would’ve been unbeatable five years ago or so.Allen,Sure Feller is the natural choice for the Indians. But Doby is not merely an emotional pick. He was a great player in his own right and it’s a travesty that he doesn’t get a fraction of the national play that Jackie gets. As for Sheff, he only had one truly great season in Florida (’96). While he’s probably the better player, I went with Conine because he was the “original Marlin”. But as you say, we’re splitting hairs. My oversight of Killebrew wasn’t intentional. At that point, I just didn’t want this post to be any longer than it already was. Killebrew’s an all-time great. Anon,Your list took me back. I used to have a Toby Harrah commemorative soft drink cup. Thanks to him, I learned what a palindrome was.

  6. Unknown's avatar Allen says:

    You’re right, Larry Doby is not “merely” an emotional choice. I just don’t give extra points to him for being the first black player in the AL, or because he hasn’t received the same acclaim that Jackie Robinson has. He was a really good player, though.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.