LOST Season Five: This Place is Death

So much to discuss about last night’s episode, and I’m writing this on my lunch break, so let’s get right to it:

  • I always love episodes with heavy doses of Sun & Jin and this episode was no exception. I just love the intricate and complex layers to their relationship. Off the Island, Sun is about to put a cap in Ben when she is told, after three years of assuming her husband was dead, that Jin is actually alive. On the Island, Jin hears Charlotte’s death bed comment (“Do not let her come back. This place is death!”) and resolves himself to do whatever it takes to keep his wife and daughter from returning. Jin gives Locke his wedding ring to prove to Sun that he’s dead; but the ring does just the opposite when Ben presents it to Sun as proof of Jin’s survival. Like I said, I just love their storyline. I just hope it’s wrapped up in a satisfying way in the end.
  • Charlotte’s death wasn’t a huge surprise; I felt that all this time travel stuff had to eventually kill somebody. Honestly, she’s had a nosebleed for pretty much the whole season, so we could see this one coming. Big revelation, though: she was born on the Island and has knowledge of a conversation with Dan from her past. Did she just remember this or has she been covering this up for some time? And why would Dan tell younger Charlotte to “leave the Island and never come back” if you can’t change the past / future? What’s the point if the “universe” is going to course correct anyway? I’m guessing we’ll learn more about Charlotte’s mysterious parents as the season progresses. Complete guess here, but I’m guessing her father might be Brother Campbell, the monk who posed for a pic with Momma Farraday.
  • I love the Smoke Monster. I really do. I have no idea what he / she / it could be (a security system?) and I doubt any final explanation will fully satisfy, but it’s just one of the coolest elements of the show. Did last night’s scene remind anybody else of the Sarlacc pit from Return of the Jedi? Au revoir, Montand.
  • Rousseau has been messed up for a long time. I’m wondering what led her and her fellow crewmates to turn on each other. I’m curious to know about the “sickness” she described in Season 1. Now that the Island seems to be “locked” in place (pun intended), maybe we’ll never know.
  • Speaking of Locke, my man of faith ventured down into the Island’s underbelly to fulfill his destiny. There he meets Christian who scolds him for not following his earlier instructions. Which leads me to wonder if Ben was ever supposed to turn the wheel in the first place. Much has been made of the fact that Jack, Kate, and the O6 were not “supposed” to leave the Island. But it seems that perhaps Ben falls into this same category. In an ironic twist, Locke is now the sacrifice the Island demands. (If you’ll remember, Locke made the same comment about Boone when he died.)
  • Favorite moment of the night: Sawyer’s expression when he recognized Jin. I loved his “Well, whadd’ya say?”
  • I want to see more of the Temple. If the Temple is where Smokey lives, could it be that the Others have always had the ability to summon him? Does the Temple also give Island-dwellers the ability to summon up the images we’ve seen in episodes past (like Eko’s brother, Kate’s horse, etc.).
  • Question: If Locke successfully “unstuck” the Island and the crazy time-flashes are over, where or when will the Island finally “land”? And how will that complicate the efforts of the Oceanic 6 (or fewer) to return to the Island?

That’s it for my thoughts. Your reaction? Again, I think this season just gets better and better from here.

This entry was posted in Television. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to LOST Season Five: This Place is Death

  1. Unknown's avatar Sunny says:

    The monster/temple scene reminded me of Austin Powers with the guy yelling out for help. I couldn’t help but laugh.I also liked it when Ben stopped the van and told Sun and Jack just how much he had done to keep everyone safe. I hope that we learn more about what all he has done or protected them from.

  2. Unknown's avatar jenna says:

    I am loving Sawyer more and more as this season goes on…. sigh…. And I do not trust Ben at all! It seems that the only time he does something to help someone else is when it is to his advantage.And next week’s episode looks like it is going to be AMAZING! I cannot wait.

  3. Unknown's avatar Dylan says:

    Random thoughts:Another great episode. There is so much going on, it’s hard to keep track of every important thing we need to remember. Remember back during the Nikki and Paulo era when we would complain about not getting any information, and now it seems like we’re almost getting too much.Jin is speaking really good English. He learned a lot fast. Plus, I realized with this episode that he has a habit of jumping from exploding boats and washing up on shore.I really liked the part where Ben through a hissy and told Jack and Sun how much he’s done for them. It almost makes me trust him. Almost.I’m also interested why Dan would tell Charlotte not to come back if he knows he can’t change the future. It was a good death scene though, and I always enjoy Giaccinno’s Life and Death playing. Plus, Daniel is quickly moving up my favorite characters rank.Thanks for the link to Brother Campbell. Very interesting..I thought we’d get a little more info from the Rousseau stuff. What happened to her crew to make them sick? That was definitely a sweet monster scene though, especially when it cut Montand’s arm off. Is that pit the same one that where Locke was being pulled in the season 1 finale until they threw the dynamite in it?I thought it was a little Pharisaic and ticky-tack for Christian/Jacob to say it was wrong that Ben turned the wheel instead of Locke. They didn’t provide a whole lot of info to Locke and Ben had to fill in the rest of the info. What does it matter that Ben turned instead of Locke? And why is that making only the Losties and Freighter folk flash through time and not the Others too?I’m glad to see Desmond again. I wonder what his role in all this is going to be.

  4. Unknown's avatar Jason says:

    I think Ben is definitely looking out for #1, but I think he was being truthful about all he's had to do in order to keep Jack and the others safe. I mean, he did have Sayid offing different "bad guys", so there's some truth there. I'm interested to see the conversation Ben and Locke had prior to Locke / Bentham's death. Dylan, I remember the Nikki & Paulo days (and the Hurley Dharma van episode) when it seemed like the producers were tap dancing. Now the info is coming fast and furious. I love it. Maybe there's another way to get some more Rousseau info. Not sure how, but I'd like to know more about how her crew went nuts. Maybe that's why she aged so much on the Island!And I'm with you, Dylan, about Christian. How was Locke supposed to know how to turn the wheel?

Leave a reply to Dylan Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.